Zen like illumination
Tuesday, August 5th, 2008In 1911, Wittgenstein went to Russell´s rooms in Trinity College, Cambridge, thrust an essay in Russell´s hand and said, “Do you think I can become a philosopher or am I wasting my time? I could remain an aeronautical engineer”. Russell read the first sentence of the essay and said, “You must become a philosopher”. I have tried hard to find what this first sentence was, and think it was “Page of contents”.
A pupil recalled handing a draft of his thesis to J.L. Austin, a leader of the Oxford school, whereupon Austin opened the file at the page of contents and proceeded to spend the next three hours discussing the differences between contents’, `list’, `index’, `table’, etc.” The pupil experienced “a Zen-like illumination”. But it faded in minutes.
This fellow has just graduated in philosophy in Chicago. Does he deserve to study philosophy further in grad school, after mauling Godel´s incompleteness theorem and ordiinary language in his essay and being puked on by Nilu? I suspect he might make a better aeronautical engineer; Or, he could stop with the contents page in his thesis.